Diamonds are a member's best friend

Diamonds are a member's best friend

Go behind the scenes with AAA Diamond inspectors to discover what it takes for hotels and restaurants to earn their coveted designations.
Emily Gnacik
A AAA Diamond Inspector holding a testing device.

Walking through Saratoga on a fall evening as leaves were starting to turn, I took in all the sights around me. There is something so magical about the Spa City at any time of year. I rounded a corner and entered a cute boutique restaurant whose menu I had obviously perused five times before the day came. The vibe inside was hip, modern, and sophisticated all at the same time. I was seated next to a big window with a decent view, and I waited. I was about to meet the people behind the inspections.

AAA has been at the forefront of the Hospitality and Tourism Industry for decades, sharing objective evaluations on restaurants and hotels with the public. The AAA Diamonds program has long been one of the most trusted ranking systems for people, giving them a credible scale of elements like luxury, location, amenities, and experiences to give realistic recommendations for travel, whether closer to home or farther away. Properties that are approved and presented with the prestigious designation will often proudly display their plaques as a rite of passage.

As I basked in the atmosphere of the restaurant, in walked Danielle, a seasoned AAA Inspector with over 20 years of site visits under her belt. Shortly thereafter, we were joined by Alison, newer to the role but equally passionate and eager to demonstrate her skills. I should probably stop here to mention that while 98% of this story is true, the Inspectors' names have been changed to keep their anonymity. Like a food critic, or a secret shopper, their job is to judge a place for the actual attainable experience, not the fictional, idyllic version. This is why they cannot reveal their identities when dining at a restaurant or when booking a room reservation. This is key. I watched as Alison carefully checked out elements like table settings, ambiance, seating arrangements, and light fixtures. See the thing is, the wait staff was super attentive and knowledgeable, but they had no idea that the three of us were in there to give them their first Diamond designation.

As we chitchatted about all the things that go into the inspection process, we sipped on curated mocktails. Mine was a delicious Lavender Mule. For the meal, first came our appetizers. Danielle had done some research ahead to make sure we ordered some of their signature dishes. The Inspectors guided me on the things they look for, including aspects like overall presentation, service, and obviously taste. Each of us had an entree of choice...I got the shrimp and grits, which you don't find often at restaurants in Upstate New York. It was one of the options off the dedicated Gluten-Free menu and it was phenomenal. Both Inspectors paid attention to how the restaurant handled my allergy. After a lovely dinner, we closed out the night sharing some creme brulee and raspberry sorbet. By this point, the sun had set and the twinkling lights above us added a subtle pop of glamour. Once we had finished our meal, they informed me that they would be recommending a Three Diamond designation for this spot. They would not reveal who we were until after we had left. We said goodnight and went our separate ways.

Three Diamonds may not sound that exciting, but all designations for AAA are based on a scale that already starts with a higher standard. The "Approved" restaurants and hotels are generally nicer than what one might expect from a Three on a generic rating model. AAA does not approve something that is not safe, clean, and decent. So... once you start getting up to Three, the experience is pleasant and reliable. Getting up to a Four, it's elevated and fancier. And, the most highly coveted, the Five Diamond...that's your most gourmet, luxurious and once-in-a-lifetime type of designation. It is incredibly difficult to get.

In the morning, Danielle, Alison, and I met again, this time inside the beautiful great room of the Saratoga Arms Hotel. This historic property was originally built in the 1870s and has the quintessential Saratoga feels. It's exactly the type of hotel I try to find for a fun getaway with a more authentic experience. After chatting for a bit on the wraparound porch and enjoying some still Saratoga water (the fancy blue bottle kind), we started our tour.

 

A traditionally decorated room with a large fireplace and painting featuring horses
The beautiful interior of the Saratoga Arms Hotel.

 

The Hotel Manager walked us around, showing us the public areas and pointing out the amenities that added a little extra something here and there. My favorite was the beverage bar at the main entrance which had complimentary tea and coffee. In the afternoons, they will put out seasonal drinks like iced tea and lemonade for summer, hot apple cider for fall, and of course, cocoa for the Holidays. We also saw the fitness center, guest pantry packed with complimentary snacks, and the bookcase for guests to use during their stay.

Once we made our way to the selected guest room, we began our inspection. I watched as Danielle took out her ATP Testing Device and began testing surfaces. One of the requirements for hotels to be AAA Approved is to pass the swab tests on areas that are frequently touched. This includes things like remote controls, toilets, and door handles. We also examined the room itself. I noticed as Alison used an eagle eye spanning the room, even though Danielle was technically the one performing the evaluation.

Entering the sleeping area, Danielle identified factors like the quality of furniture, the comfort of the sheets, the appearance of the bedspread and upholstery. She pointed out little details like the placement of the outlets and the amenities present within the room. Inside the bathroom, we found elegant staging which included Beekman 1802 products both at the sink and inside the shower. This is just one example of features that might seem to be insignificant, but make a big difference in what feels luxurious to a guest.

 

A hotel room featuring a bed, desk, and lamps.
A guest room at the Saratoga Arms Hotel.

 

Saratoga Arms Hotel is one of the only Four Diamond properties in the greater Capital Region of New York State. Honestly, I felt so comfortable there I didn't want to leave. Sometimes I forget how incredible some places are right in my own backyard. Following the Inspectors around, I realized how much care and thought goes into every single site visit. Every little thing matters. The designation is in the details. It became abundantly clear to me just what it takes for a restaurant or hotel to not only pass, but to get up into the upper echelon. That Four Diamond plaque prominently displayed right next to the front door of Saratoga Arms Hotel means a lot to them. And as a AAA Member, it means a lot to me to know what these businesses go through to be scored so highly.

In a world full of reviews by AI bots and paid media influencers, it's nice to know that AAA is still actually doing the work, and giving people unbiased feedback.

Emily Gnacik is a AAA Editor in Upstate New York.

 

Learn more about the AAA Diamonds program and discover highly rated hotels and restaurants for your next getaway.

AAA DIAMOND PROGRAM

Tags: